6
$\begingroup$

In the days of legend, when the World Tree was but freshly sprouted, and many of the gods still newly born, they say the first sapient creatures began life upon the surface of the Earth. Among them were the creatures of Feyrie, who live a life eternal beyond the barrier of twilight that enshrouds their realms. Dying not, they live on unchanged through what, to mortals, would be many turns of time's great wheel.

Governed justly (although I shall not say beneficently) by the Feyrie Queen, the many species of faerie creature - the impish pixies, brave sprites and frankly rather odious goblins among them - were content with their unending existence. But the spiritual elves, those wise hunters and brilliant musicians, were not content. Something made almost the full complement of the elvish species cross the twilight barrier and join the ordinary mortal species (such as the dwarves, halflings and humans) in the world not sheltered from the ravages of ageing, and therefore render themselves mortal, although they remained relatively long-lived from a mortal point of view. As if this were not difficulty enough for the elves, those other mortal species no doubt at first feared and distrusted the elves, who were at that time strange to them.

Even then, during the Elder Days, the source of all the strangest things in our history, what could have driven so many elves to make such a great sacrifice - never once returning to the lands from which their people came? And who can say what, if anything, they hoped to gain in return?

Whatever the case, this much is clear: the elves live among us even now, in their hidden woodland abodes and secret coastal harbours. Although their number is not so great as that of the humans or dwarves, they number enough to be among the more populous species in the world. They bring sword and bow to bear against any who threaten their homes or lives, and they broadly fight fiercely against evil (although there are those who claim that elves are, on the whole, not so kind as their reputation might lead one to believe). They are also skilled in the Arts Magic, with a particular preference for druidic ritual and calling upon feyrie spirits.


Here are some additional constraints.

  • Gunpowder and industrial technology have always eluded even the most skilled philosophers, and I have no reason to believe that the Elder Days were any different. Our world relies mostly on the work we can do with our hands, and of course the Arts Magical.
  • The Feyrie peoples alone possess the knowledge of the reason for the elves' exodus, and it is never shared with mortals, even by the elves who left Feyrie.
  • Not all the elves left Feyrie. A few remained behind and renamed themselves 'eladrin'. They became the honour guard of the Feyrie Queen, and remain immortal.
  • 'Elf' must remain a compelling player option for a player in a tabletop roleplaying game. This means that each elf cannot be superhumanly powerful or incredibly weak, and they must be capable of choosing from a variety of professions (to enable a player to choose freely from a wide selection of character classes). They must also broadly be susceptible to the same infirmities - poison, disease, final death - as the other mortal species (otherwise they would be too powerful to allow a player to be one!).
$\endgroup$
3
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Please explain your last bullet point. Why would the reason elves became mortal have anything to do with the RPG? If it has a reason (which would probably invalidate the question as it becomes one of a game mechanic and not worldbuilding), can players play either the immortal or the mortal elves? And then there's the lists of "they must also be..." items. What, specifically and exactly! are you asking of us? $\endgroup$ Commented 2 days ago
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Hi, Soft. This question feels very open-ended, and unforgivingly plot-based. Substack isn't suited for "Please fix this plot point for me" kinds of questions. How will you identify a best answer? In every world I've read about, such a broad decision happens after some momentous event makes everyone see the error in a philosophy. There are always pluses and minuses to immortality. Vampire stories alone provide a wealth of them. $\endgroup$ Commented 18 hours ago
  • $\begingroup$ To be immortal means to be cursed with perfect foresight and thus no suprise. Only with mortality does that "curse" of perfect knowledge about the future end. They know they are doomed to fade.. $\endgroup$ Commented 11 hours ago

5 Answers 5

17
$\begingroup$

The key word is "unchanged". The world beyond the twilight barrier is deathless, but also timeless. No change there can ever last.

The Feyrie Queen's rule will never end so long as she stays there. Her kingdom is an endless summer day where not so much as a flower will ever wilt, but no new plants will ever grow either. The elves were born with knowledge of many skills and magics, but they can never learn new ones. Only contact with the material world can change them, for good or ill.

They did not come here to die. They came here to live.

... with that in mind, it should have been impossible for them to cross the twilight barrier in the first place. The great secret of the elves is what exactly was able to reach into their timeless realm and grant them the power to make that choice. Perhaps someone from our side fetched them here?

$\endgroup$
0
5
$\begingroup$

Children Sinple immortals can't have children, this is a common enough idea. They see humans and dwarves having children, growing and changing. For some it jealousy, for some its fear of being outnumbered, for others its the desire ot parenthood, some even see the power tp evolve that reproduction gives. But the result is the same become mortal to make your species able to grow and change.

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

But the spiritual elves, those wise hunters and brilliant musicians, were not content

One does not need to question existence to be a brave sprite -- one just needs to press on in the face of fear. One does not need to question existence to be a mischievous pixie -- the moment is now and the prank is ready. The odious goblins may not have the opportunity to question -- their nature may make them less liked, and have to focus more on surviving.

But the spiritual elves grew wise, and in their wisdom began to ask Questions. In their endless lives, they go through the motions of prayer, the trappings of faith, and even reverence to their Queen. But something is missing and niggling at them.

The hunters hunt and kill to sustain their homes -- they are aware of death in the sense that it exists, but as it visits them so infrequently are fundamentally unaware of what death is. The bards (musicians) write epic pieces telling grand tales, but there are only so many tales to tell in a world of endless life and eternal twilight.

And so, one by one, they left. Individuals with ambition and wanderlust, Clans and Families looking for a deeper spiritual means to their endless existence. Scholars and Philosophers searching the mortal realms for Answers that their immortal lives could not provide. A thousand people with hundreds of reasons crossed the barrier of the realms.

But by giving up their immortality, they also gave up the immunities that came with said endless life. Death can now reach them in all the ways that it could not before, and will now inevitably do so.

So while the Feyrie Folk know why the elves left, there is no monolithic reason that they did. The elves themselves do not answer because the decision of their ancestors to shed their immortality was a deeply personal and spiritual one (or rather embarrassing in hindsight), so they remain silent.

That leaves the Eladrin. They are the elves that stayed, because they found their Answers in the Feyrie Queen. As their spirituality and faith started to turn to the Queen, so too did the Queen reward with with positions of honour.

In short, their very spirituality lead most of them to depart eventually.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Only cruelty awaits the immortals

The reign of Feyrie Queen is just, but unforgething. Quite literally. unforgething.

Nothing is even forgotten, as there are no decaying bodies or minds. Any decay would mean a very cruel fate to mortals themselves.

But no decaying, then, would mean very much a cruel existence, as any and all unfriendly words or acts will never be forgotten.

So, only cruelty awaits the immortals, at least compared to the mortal ways.

There is decaying. There is forgetting. There is a chance to progress into something that is not cruel as living forever, and forever remembering the accumulating all unjust and unfriendly acts and words, that can only grow as the times passes.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

A related question that goes hand in hand with your question is: Why don't the mortal elves decide to go back?
An easy answer to this is: The mortal elves (or all mortals in general) either can't go back or they are not allowed to go back to the immortal lands.
I leave it to you to invent a proper reason that fits your story (the will of the queen; a property of the barrier; a hard rule of the immortal land; ...).

Without the possibility or permission to go back, the expelling from the immortal land can be used as a punishment with a slow but guaranteed death sentence.
So the founders of the mortal elves had to leave the immortal land against their will or left for personal reasons (e.g. out of curiosity for the outside world; a wife following her expelled husband; ...).
Again, I leave it to you to invent the details so that they match your story.

The descendants of the founders also share the same fate that they can't or are not allowed to go back to the immortal land, but unlike their founders, they are already used to live in the mortal lands. Depending on several circumstances, the current living mortal elves may or may not know the reasons why the founders were expelled.
Yet again, this offers a lot of possible details to tell a story and I leave the details for you. (Were they told about the original expelling reasons and is that the truth? Do they hold a grudge against their immortal siblings or is that a detail which doesn't matter anymore?)

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.