7

Please let me know if there are other SEs more appropriate for this question.

At more or less the halfway point of de la Boétie's short essay 'Discourse on Voluntary Servitude' he mentions the following situation:

  • Two Spartans Espércias and Búlis (names in a recent Portuguese edition) are sent to the Persian empire (as retribution for the assassination of two Persian ambassadors)
  • They reach the palace of Hidarnes, a general in the Persian army, who tells them that Xerxes would/could reward them with power over a Greek city (were they to switch sides I guess)
  • In reply, the Spartans say something along the lines of "we who know true liberty can't be swayed by such things. If you (Hidarnes) knew about it too, you would advise us to defend it with all our energies"

I haven't been able to find any source for this anecdote. I even think it might be apocryphal, as (to me) it doesn't seem consistent with the Spartan values/thinking.

I would appreciate anyone pointing to the original source, or a confirmation that this was made up.

Many thanks!

New contributor
augustoperez is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.

1 Answer 1

11

The incident de la Boétie is referring to appears in Herodotus' (c. 484 – c. 425 BCE) Histories, of which various copies can be found online. Below is the relevant excerpt (from Volume 2, translated by G. C. Macaulay):

...Sperthias the son of Aneristos and Bulis the son of Nicolaos, Spartans of noble birth and in wealth attaining to the first rank, voluntarily submitted to pay the penalty to Xerxes for the heralds of Dareios which had perished at Sparta. Thus the Spartans sent these to the Medes [i.e. Persians - see note below] to be put to death.

And not only the courage then shown by these men is worthy of admiration, but also the following sayings in addition: for as they were on their way to Susa they came to Hydarnes (now Hydarnes was a Persian by race and commander of those who dwelt on the sea coasts of Asia), and he offered them hospitality and entertained them; and while they were his guests he asked them as follows: "Lacedemonians, why is it that ye flee from becoming friends to the king? for ye may see that the king knows how to honour good men, when ye look at me and at my fortunes. So also ye, Lacedemonians, if ye gave yourselves to the king, since ye have the reputation with him already of being good men, would have rule each one of you over Hellenic land by the gift of the king." To this they made answer thus: "Hydarnes, thy counsel with regard to us is not equally balanced, 117 for thou givest counsel having made trial indeed of the one thing, but being without experience of the other: thou knowest well what it is to be a slave, but thou hast never yet made trial of freedom, whether it is pleasant to the taste or no; for if thou shouldest make trial of it, thou wouldest then counsel us to fight for it not with spears only but also with axes."

Prior to this in Herodotus' text, he gives the Spartans' reasoning for sending Sperthias and Bulis. In short, it was because a series of unfavourable omens:

...in Sparta there is a temple of Talthybios, and there are also descendants of Talthybios called Talthybiads, to whom have been given as a right all the missions of heralds which go from Sparta; and after this event it was not possible for the Spartans when they sacrificed to obtain favourable omens. This was the case with them for a long time; and as the Lacedemonians were grieved and regarded it as a great misfortune, and general assemblies were repeatedly gathered together and proclamation made, asking if any one of the Lacedemonians was willing to die for Sparta...

NOTE: Herodotus used the term 'Medes' instead of 'Persians', which was not uncommon among Greeks in early 5th century BCE. As the Encyclopaedia Iranica notes, "The Persians generally are run together with the Medes, as can be recognized by Herodotus’s use of the terms mēdízein and mēdismós"

0

Your Answer

Draft saved
Draft discarded

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.